24 Comments

Having more government involved in any part of this won't fix anything. People need to want to be in more rural areas. Making grads be in a certain place for x years, meeting specific quotas, making new laws, etc will only have the opposite effect. Less government, less taxes, less regulation fixes all things. When the free market can decide where, when, how, and how much then things society will find a way to make it work. Government creating artificial scenarios never works.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and adding your perspective. In this particular case, I share your point of view. Forcing a doctor who would rather practice in a big city to move to the country is probably not going to work in the long run. There are many other options (e.g. empowering nurses and setting up a PA system) that would probably be more effective.

Expand full comment

All of whatā€™s proposed here, much like incentives to relocate families or Kyotoā€™s tourism problem, donā€™t look at underlying structural issues, the root cause, which, of course, is complex but boils down to the unfortunate fact that most rural areas have created for themselves by way of the status quo or have had created for them an image of patheticness, a an endlessly repeating spiral of self-defeat.

Thatā€™s not what some places actually are, but after so many years of convincing themselves of their podunk-ness, theyā€™ve become rather podunk, assumed that role, and with that comes the whittling away of resources, doctors included. Like any tailspin, itā€™s hard to come back from - and some, probably many, wonā€™t.

As much as I love Tohoku - I lived in Miyako on the coast of Iwate from 2009-2011, got wrecked by the tsunami there, still have very strong ties - its situation is mostly too far gone to make good use of the resources Japan is able to muster right now to address the issue.

As I do with akiya, there are easy wins, lost causes, and everything in between. What must be done in the short term to affect a more positive long term is to tactically determine those easy wins and achieve them one by one.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and thinking about this situation, especially from your perspective of living in a part of Tohoku devastated by 3-11.

While I agree that there are many places that are already too far gone, there are several bright spots scattered throughout the countryside. As I argued in the article, much of this particular problem is rooted in the artificial restrictions placed on the delivery of medical care in Japan by doctors. If more nurse practitioners, for example, were empowered to do more on their own, then large swaths of the rural population would likely receive far better care.

I take your point that many rural areas seem to be poorly managed by people whose attitude seems to be "woe is me"; there are enthusiastic advocates for positive change who need to be nurtured. If physician organizations were more realistic about how to deliver health care effectively in rural areas, and more willing to relinquish some control, the rural-urban divide might not be so great.

Expand full comment

This is a major factor in my opinion that the Japanese Governmentā€™s push for moving families to rural areas from cities is ludicrous; younger folx without so many immediate medical needs or commitments should be the ones on the frontier, not Moms and Dads who are already having a hard time of it in Meguro.

Expand full comment
author

As a former resident of Meguro-ku, I can attest to the relatively high cost of living there. While everyone's situation is different, you might be surprised at the high quality of life and relatively reasonable cost of living that is possible in rural Japan. Some villages - not just those that have already experienced significant depopulation - even offer all kinds of subsidies for young families with children.

Expand full comment

Great piece, thank you. Here's an article (in Japanese) from the Yomiuri that highlights another dimension of the divide--the growing shortage of coroners, especially outside the major urban areas. Japan is already approaching the end of forensic pathology as a part of its medical system. https://www.yomiuri.co.jp/national/20241005-OYT1T50048/

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and the positive feedback. The acute shortage of pathologists is certainly another unintended consequence of depopulation, and the long-term population decline has only just begun. What a strange problem to have! Hopefully, would-be murderers are still unaware of this situation. If they were, however, the map would provide some clues as to where a would-be criminal might best be able to get away with such a heinous crime. This is worrying as I live in one of the dark shaded areas!

Expand full comment

I think you're probably pretty safe from foul play where you live in Japan. I think you're also right about long-term population decline just beginning. People underestimate the entropy of depopulation. Immigration is not a solution, in light of declining birth rates around the world.

Expand full comment

I wonder if some kind of rotation like a residency program could help. I am not familiar with how education is funded in Japan but, if medical students are running up a debt as in the US, there could be a debt forgiveness for practicing in a target region for a period of time. These new Drs might start off thinking they want to resettle to a big metropolis, but perhaps after they have a chance to build a sense of community in their underserved area, a percentage of them might change their minds and stay.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and leaving a comment. Yes, that is the intent of the quota system.

Expand full comment

While Iā€™m not personally for forcing someone to have to work in a certain place, I absolutely understand the problem going on. As someone who lives in Aomori prefecture, itā€™s easy to see that with the lack of doctors also means a lack of good healthcare. And probably one of the reasons Aomori the lowest life expectancy in Japan.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and leaving a comment. You are on the front lines of this issue. I have a feeling that your belief about the possible connection to life expectancy is, in fact, probably true.

Expand full comment

Thank you for another informative newsletter, Mark! I was surprised by some of the prefectures with the most doctors.

Expand full comment

Create an effective telemedicine system nationwide. This could reduce pressure on all hospitals, freeing them up to deal with urgent cases.

Expand full comment
author

Thanks for reading and commenting. Yes, I agree that telemedicine should be an integral part of the overall strategy. It has already been adopted by some rural hospitals, but there is obviously much more room to encourage more widespread use.

Expand full comment

é–¢ę±äø­å¤®ē—…é™¢ć«å‹¤å‹™ć—ć¦ć„ć‚‹åœØę—„ęœé®®äŗŗć®ćƒ‰ć‚Æć‚æćƒ¼ćÆ态6幓前ē½¹ć£ćŸę™‚态åæ™ć—恄ꙂćÆ35ę™‚é–“å‹¤å‹™ć—ć¦ć„ć‚‹ćØčØ€ć£ć¦ć„ć¾ć—ćŸć€‚é©šē•°ēš„ć§ć™ć€‚ćć†ć„ć†äŗŗćŒå›½ē«‹ć‚„å…¬ē«‹ē—…é™¢ć«ćÆć„ć‚‰ć£ć—ć‚ƒć‚‹ćØę€ć„ć¾ć™ć®ć§ć€é¤Šč€å­Ÿåø先ē”ŸćŒęå”±ć—ć¦ć„ć‚‹åœ°ę–¹ćøć®å®šęœŸēš„ćŖ参勤äŗ¤ä»£ćŒåæ…要恠ćØę€ć„ć¾ć—ćŸć€‚é¦–éƒ½åœć§å‹¤å‹™ć™ć‚‹åŒ»č€…ć‚’åœ°ę–¹ć§ę•°é€±é–“ćŖć„ć—ę•°å¹“å‹¤å‹™ć•ć›ć‚‹ć®ć§ć™ć€‚å¼·åˆ¶ć§ć€‚ćƒÆć‚Æćƒćƒ³ć§ćŸćć•ć‚“å„²ć‘ćŸć®ć§ćć®ćć‚‰ć„ć‚ˆć‚ć—ććŠé”˜ć„ć—ć¾ć™ć‚ˆšŸ™šŸ™‡ā€ā™€ļøć€‚

Expand full comment
author

恊čŖ­ćæć„ćŸć ćć€ć‚³ćƒ”ćƒ³ćƒˆć‚’ę®‹ć—ć¦ćć ć•ć‚Šć‚ć‚ŠćŒćØć†ć”ć–ć„ć¾ć™ć€‚åŒ»åø«ć«35ę™‚é–“ć¾ćŸćÆ36ę™‚é–“ć®ć‚·ćƒ•ćƒˆå‹¤å‹™ć‚’ć•ć›ć‚‹ćØć„ć†ę…£č”ŒćÆ态恊恝悉恏čŖ°ć«ćØć£ć¦ć‚‚ęœ€å–„ć§ćÆćŖ恄ćØć„ć†ę„č¦‹ć«ć‚±ćƒćƒ‡ć‚£ć‚‚åŒę„ć—ć¾ć™ć€‚é–“é•ć„ćÆ起恓悋悂恮恧恙怂

é¦–éƒ½åœć«å‹¤å‹™ć™ć‚‹åŒ»åø«ć«ć€åœ°ę–¹ć§ćƒ‘ćƒ¼ćƒˆć‚æć‚¤ćƒ å‹¤å‹™ć‚’ć•ć›ć‚‹ćØć„ć†ć‚¢ć‚¤ćƒ‡ć‚¢ćÆć€ćƒ”ćƒŖ惃惈恌恂悋ćØę€ć„ć¾ć™ć€‚

Expand full comment

As the populations gets even smaller doctors will shrink even more as well. True, less patients as well. But if they don't shrink proportionally its going to make it even worse.

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and sharing your perspective. I agree. The situation in Tohoku seems to be a classic case of how what you describe can play out.

Expand full comment

I think you're right about financial incentives having a major role to play. I don't know about Japanese doctors; but my experience of doctors in other countries in which I have lived is that too many of them are in it for the money. I used to know a Scandinavian doctor who had a one-year contract to teach medicine to undergrads at a prestigious Asian university. He told me how shocked he was that his students showed little or no interest in how to be good doctors. They just wanted to know how to pass their exams.

Offering higher salaries and/or lower taxes to work in the relevant prefectures seems like a no-brainer. Importing trained medical staff from overseas has worked well in some countries. In Japan's case, the language barrier would be an issue; but doctors are smart people and would probably be willing to learn Japanese if the salary, terms and conditions of employment were right.

Having said all that effecting change will require leadership, common sense and imagination, all of which - perhaps like doctors - seem to be in short supply in Japan.

Despite my usual cynicism, however, I would like to pay tribute to the exemplary patience, care, kindness and professionalism of all the staff who took care of me at a Japanese hospital where I had surgery last week - and thank God for Google Translate!

Expand full comment
author

Thank you for reading and leaving a comment. First of all, it sounds like you are making a speedy recovery from your surgery, which is great.

As I suggest in the article, I have a feeling that this problem is not going to be solved simply by offering financial incentives to get more doctors to practice in rural areas. Empowering advanced practice nurses and possibly establishing the role of a physician assistant would probably be more realistic in the long run.

Expand full comment

Yes, I don't disagree; but I do think that financial incentives would be relatively quick and simple measure to take compared with re-structuring the care system. Provided that the financial incentives are not just a few yen here and there, they could be very effective. On the other hand, I doubt that the policrims in Tokyo with their grubby fingers on the purse strings would be too happy seeing their best doctors re-locating to the countryside to take care of the serfs! So maybe financial incentives are another non-starter?!

Come to think of it, I did read about a study which allegedly showed that AI is already better at producing accurate diagnoses than the human doctors involved in the study; so maybe AI is starting to offer a contribution to the problem at the primary care level?

Whatever happens, I do think that medicine is heading for a major shake-up. Apart from changes in technology, I think there is a lot of disillusionment with allopathic medicine, especially after all the propaganda, lies and nonsense in recent years about "safe and effective."

Expand full comment
author

Yes, AI is already proving itself as a diagnostic tool. My feeling is, however, that there will always be a need for the human touch - literally - to provide quality medical care.

Expand full comment
Error